| A Review of: The Wire: Truth Be Told by Greg GatenbyThinking people are fond of trashing television as an intellectual
wasteland, although it has been my observation that book people are
rather too conversant with the details of several shows which their
trashing (and claims to never watch) should in principle prohibit
them from knowing. One of the programs I found that book people
rarely if ever watched was Imprint, a show that started so well
years ago under Daniel Richler's aegis but which devolved into an
embarrassment to the book trade-indeed, was an embarrassment to the
human mind, so confused was its mission, and so appallingly priggish
was its hosting. Yet for those with cable or satellite, there has
been one program where the writer (rather than the director or
actor) dominates: The Wire. The noted American novelist Richard
Price has not only penned episodes, he has even appeared, albeit
briefly, on screen. Another feted novelist who has written for the
series is George Pelecanos. One of the distinguishing features of
the program, set in the ghettoes and in the city hall of Baltimore,
is its unflinching verisimilitude. So accurate is the program, the
Mayor of Baltimore tried to have the shooting of subsequent episodes
banned. Black people actually commit horrible crimes in The Wire,
something rarely seen in American fictional programming-such is the
medium's fear of giving offence. And the show is merciless-and
witty-at illuminating civic corruption. Unfortunately, I watched
it before the Gomery Commission began its revelations; now, in
retrospect, The Wire seems almost Canadian. Given my affection for
the TV show, I had hoped the book documenting its origins and
evolution would be of a similar high standard. Regrettably, it is
not, and I consider it a public service to dissuade you from buying
the book, for not only will I save you money, you will not, if you
haven't seen the show as yet, be put off from viewing it. The book,
The Wire, is largely a padded, scene by scene prose exposition of
each hour-length drama. Its organization seems to have been an
afterthought by the editor. For example, cast-lists and production-credits
which, logically, should appear within the delineations of each
program, are stuck at the back as an appendix, forcing the reader
to move back and forth, hoping that his finger doesn't slip from
the appropriate page. Worse, the book covers only the first two
seasons. A third has already aired, and the fourth is scheduled for
2006. Almost everything in the book can be found at the program's
webpage: www.hbo.com/thewire.
|