| A Review of: Here Today by Olga SteinThe assassination of President John F. Kennedy on November 22, 1963
changed a great number of lives. For Eleanor Dingman, it meant the
falling apart of her family. Her mother, Doris Day Dingman, beautiful,
overambitious and self-absorbed, takes Jackie Kennedy's drastically
changed circumstances as a cue. Life is too short, she decides. She
can't wait for what she wants to happen; instead she must make' it
happen by leaving her life and family in suburban Spectacle behind
and heading for New York and its showbiz opportunities. Here Today
is about a woman who is dissatisfied with her ordinary life-her
small, older home in a cul-de-sac that isn't one of the nicer streets
in a mid-sized American town, and her domestic responsibilities to
her husband and three children. Obsessed with the idea of fame, she
takes acting classes, auditions for town theatre productions, and
does everything possible to get ahead', letting her 11-year-old
daughter do the cooking for the family. She convinces the owner
of the local department store-where she can't afford to shop-to put
on a fall display of the latest fashions so that she could model
for the occasion. But something inside Doris Day Dingman snaps when
she auditions but isn't chosen for the part of Circus Girl, spokeswoman
for a chain of restaurants, and when, soon after that, the Harvest
Parade, for which she had lobbied just for the chance to be the
Harvest Queen, is cancelled because of Kennedy's death.
Here Today isn't Doris's story. It's her daughter's story. We see
the consequences of Doris's behaviour-her slightly vulgar style of
dressing and her undisguised desire to stand out, which elicits
derision from many who witness her antics-through Eleanor's eyes.
It is her pain we're shown as she's forced to cope first with the
emotionally distant ways of her mother, and then her full absence
from her and her sibling's lives. Eleanor and her small world-the
kids in her school, her best friend Holly, her sister and brother,
and the four other atypical families living on her street, misfits
by the standards of 1960s middle-class America-are wonderfully
rendered by Ann M. Martin. Martin has cleverly captured the period
with her descriptions of clothing, common phrases, and even the
food that a lower middle-class family like the Dingmans would have
for dinner. She has also captured the darker side of 1960s suburban
America: the snobbery of the town's residents, which filters down
to their children, and shapes their behavior towards other kids
from families of modest means; the mild anti-semitism; the
censoriousness towards unwed mothers or towards women like the
kindly Miss Woods and Miss Nelson whose house is on Eleanor's street
and who "are unrelated but live together." We are shown
the cruelty of Eleanor's class mates as they conspire to hurt both
Eleanor and Holly physically and emotionally. The cruelty is part
and parcel of the town's mores: Eleanor and Holly are considered
weird' because Eleanor isn't dressed as well as the other girls and
because Holly was born out of wedlock. Most moving of all is Eleanor's
struggle to hold on to her mother, despite her inability to relate
to Doris's ambitions, and her eventual realization that she can't
hold on. "You've been leaving forever," Eleanor tells
Doris when she turns up unexpectedly to announce that she is moving
to Hollywood ("to give her career one more chance") and
to gather up the last of her belongings left in the Dingman's home.
Sitting with her father and being comforted by him while Doris is
packing upstairs, Eleanor finally understands and accepts that she
and her siblings will manage without Doris. I recommend this novel
for girls eleven to fourteen years of age, though it can be read
and fully enjoyed by older readers as well.
|