| A Review of: Refusal Shoes by Tim McGrenereThe 2003 movie, Love, Actually, opens with a series of sugar-sweet
soft-glow images of London's Heathrow Airport-all huggy and kissy
reunions at the baggage carousels and Hugh Grant, in a breathless
voiceover saying "love, actually is all around' Well, in Tony
Saint's first novel, Refusal Shoes-a searing and brutally funny
portrait of corrupt immigration officers at Heathrow-love isn't
anywhere to be found. In fact, love has been refused entry and
cannot even claim asylum.
Saint's book arrived with some controversy in England where it was
published in 2003. An immigration officer himself, Saint was suspended
from work when word of the book got out. He handed in his resignation
shortly thereafter. The Home Office requested to see a proof to
check that it didn't contravene the Official Secrets Act. They
insisted that Saint make it clear at all times that it was 100% a
work of fiction or, they threatened, they'd act against him. You
can't pay for that kind of publicity.
Reading the book, it's easy to see why the Home Office was nervous.
The "fictional" Terminal C is portrayed as one of the
dark junctions of globalization hell, and Saint's vivid and assured
writing pulls the reader into a kind of voyeuristic trance. We see
the grey walls and the dark endless corridors of Heathrow and the
indolent and nefarious members of the immigration service, each
wearing clothes that, in a running joke, they "always wear".
We feel the cold blast of the air conditioners working hard in
November. We smell the stale coffee, stale cigarettes and stale
booze, not to mention the human sweat in the overcrowded holding
rooms. We hear the violent bangaboomabang of the passport stamps
and the whirling of the arrival's board. And most of all we are
privy to the intensely cynical backroom conversations of the
immigration officers talking about "knocking off the duffers
and scrotes."
Heathrow is not only a character in the novel; it becomes a symbol
of the real tribal divisions that simmer beneath One-World Global
Village pieties. In one memorable passage, the narrator describes
in detail the hatreds between various nationalities and races. It
begins with the more mundane hatred between Arabs and Jews-"Everybody
knows that," intones the narrator, and proceeds to give an
encyclopedic account of the various national hatreds, which achieves
its frenzied climax in the following:
Albanians hate Serbs, who hate Turks, who hate Russians, who hate
Croats, who hate Greeks, who hate Macedonians, who hate Albanians.
Norwegians hate Swedes. Really. Belgians hate each other. People
from Portsmouth hate people from Southampton. In the real world,
hatred is the only thing we do have in common.
And the Immigration Service runs on it. It is character building
when it comes to this kind of work; it is positively encouraged.
It is a natural resource, available in abundance and self-generatingThe
art of the [immigration officers] is to take that hatred and focus
and redistribute it on the arriving passengers.
Clearly, Saint is not dipping us in Hollywood sentimentality. His
book is often claustrophobic with hatred. Like the novel's immigration
officer protagonist, Henry Brinks, the reader feels trapped by that
hatred. Although we may be compelled by the truth of Saint's
portrayal, at the book's halfway point our only desire, like that
of Henry Brinks, is to escape Heathrow.
Saint manages to make the reader sympathetic to Brink's situation
even though he spends little time developing his character or giving
the reader information about Brink's life outside Heathrow. And to
a great extent this narrow focus is justified; Brinks is a man whose
character, whose soul, has been crushed by Terminal C. He has been
de-sensitized and de-humanized by his work. At the beginning of the
novel we see a passive and ignoble near-drone whose entire personality
is summed up by the mantra of Terminal C: "Cover your back."
He is pathetic. But when Brinks is threatened by the most corrupt
immigration officer of all, a spark of character is reignited and
he attempts to overcome his own passivity and the "raw, almost
unbearable cruelty" that is Heathrow. Brinks does inspire
compassion. Clearly, he is caught between two extreme perspectives
on the would-be immigrants he deals with. He does not share the
cruel racism of his fellow officers, who believe every refugee is
a fraud come to live on the dole; nor can he side with the liberals
who believe that every single person who claims asylum is instantly
entitled to it. Brinks has seen too many frauds, but again, not
enough to justify such cynical exercises of power as the semi-official
competition between immigration officers for most "knock-offs"
in a year and the practice of refusing entry based on the type of
shoes a passenger is wearing.
There is a thriller aspect to the story, and while the plot has its
charms and a satisfying conclusion, it definitely takes second place
to Saint's clinical dissection of Heathrow's Kafkaesque horrors.
That, and Saint's deft comic sensibility, makes for a truly gripping
read. If you liked Love, Actually and want to hold on to its syrupy
Heathrow dreamscape then stay away from this book. But if what
you're after is a lifelike account of one volatile intersection
point of today's globalized movement of people, then grab this book.
You'll never pass through airport customs with inappropriate footwear
again.
|