| A Review of: The Hours by Cindy MacKenzieAs evidenced by the change in cover design that now features three
"superstar" actresses, Meryl Streep, Julianne Moore, and
Nicole Kidman, the release of director Stephen Daldry's highly
lauded 2002 film adaptation of Michael Cunningham's The Hours has
promoted a resurgence of interest in the 1998 Pulitzer-prize winning
novel. Unlike so many adaptations of book to film, the two forms
of this novel are, in fact, highly complementary in their sensitive
and beautifully-wrought treatment of the dark terrains of madness,
depression, and homoeroticism that inform the pervading theme of
love. So, if you've seen the film, do not hesitate to read the
book (or vice versa)- you only stand to enrich your understanding
and admiration of both the story and the author's artistry in telling
it.
Cunningham's imaginatively interwoven three-level plot, founded on
Virginia Woolf's masterpiece Mrs. Dalloway, resonates with the
complex sensibilities of Woolf herself-her homoerotic desire, her
depression, her madness and her genius. Taking a daring plunge below
the surface of things in much the same way that Woolf's character,
in the opening scene, enters the water with rocks in the pockets
of her coat, the novel explores the burden of "suppressed
desire", the difficulty of living a split life. As Adrienne
Rich states in Lies, Secrets, and Silence, this is "an extremely
painful and dangerous way to live"; that is, to be "split
between a publicly acceptable persona, and a part of yourself that
you perceive as the essential, the creative and powerful self, yet
also as possibly unacceptable, perhaps even monstrous." The
consequences of this split, moreover, often result in madness,
depression, and loneliness, the psychological conditions that plague
the characters in the novel. But in the end, Cunningham draws not
only a compassionate picture of the vicissitudes of all kinds of
love and passion but also offers a triumphant resolution that
embraces and enlarges its expression.
Transitions between the three subplots are artfully rendered by the
oblique but insistent connections between stories-different scenes,
different characters, but the problems and solutions of each move
in an ongoing spiral of variations on shared themes. The book opens
with Virginia Woolf writing the first sentence of Mrs. Dalloway,
then shifts to the character of housewife Laura Brown reading the
first page of the novel in Los Angeles in 1949, and finally moves
to our present and that of Clarissa Vaughn, nicknamed "Mrs.
Dalloway" by her gay friend Richard, a writer who is dying of
AIDS. Clarissa, like Woolf's character Mrs. Dalloway, is planning
a celebratory dinner party for her complicated and emotionally
tormented friend-vexations that drive him equally to moments of
passionate love and rage. Cunningham's plots intersect in subtle
and intricate ways, echoing Woolf's own artistic methodology as
stated in the novel's epigraph: "I dig out beautiful caves
behind my characters; the caves shall connect, & each comes to
daylight at the present moment." And in the end, those
"caves" behind the characters do connect-in ways, moreover,
that are startling and revelatory.
Love in this novel is a weighty consideration, as it is always
placed contiguously with death, a position that lends itself to the
more philosophical considerations of a chthonic love, a "soul
love", one that embraces all of the subterranean complexities
and expressions of that most enigmatic of human emotions. Clarissa's
inner struggle with her feelings for Richard, and all that she
rejected over thirty years ago, is representative of the struggle
with our own illusions that conflict with the more sensible
considerations of living with ground beneath our feet. So Clarissa
sensibly opts to accept the beauty of the ordinariness of life, of
her life with lover, Sally, and "not to imagine that other
future, that rejected future as a vast and endearing romance laid
over friendship so searing and profound it could accompany them to
the grave and possibly beyond. She could, she thinks, have entered
another world. She could have had a life as potent and dangerous
as literature itself." Now, facing the stark reality of
Richard's spiritual death as he nears the end of his physical life-he
smells, he's cynical, unhappy, unfulfilled, and professing his love
for her even though he's gay, she's lesbian-Clarissa knows that her
decision was right, that it would have been impossible to live with
Richard's passion nor could it have been sustained from day to day.
It is, in fact, clear that loving Richard can only be, as it was
for others who tried, a "long doomed project" and so she
was wise to abandon it "in favor of simpler pleasures."
Although she attempts to convince him of the value of what's left
of his life, he cannot endure it, saying: "but there are still
the hours, aren't there? One and then another." For Richard,
there is simply too much time to live with the burden of his pain,
his regrets, and his disease, so he chooses, like Virginia Woolf,
to end his life.
Meanwhile, Laura Brown contemplates suicide because she's unfulfilled
as a 50's wife and mother. Her own suppressed desire leads her
toward thoughts of Virginia Woolf as "virginal, unbalanced,
defeated by the impossible demands of life and art," and
"she is glad to know that it is possible to stop living. There
is comfort in facing the full range of options; in considering all
your choices, fearlessly and without guile." But the startling
ending of Laura's story will peel the scales from readers' eyes
when they find out what options she takes.
The three stories are connected by the image of a single kiss, its
power to open up a vision of the future and fill it with hope.
Cunningham brilliantly defines it through Clarissa's words, as
"one's greatest point of optimism converging in one kiss an
intense yearning for all that is possible in love." When
Virginia kisses Vanessa, she describes it as "full of a love
complex and ravenous, ancient," as the "kiss that would
sustain her." Clarissa remembers Richard's kiss as "singular
perfection, in part because it seemed, so clearly to promise more.
Now she knows: That was the moment, right then. There has been no
other." And when Laura kisses her friend Kitty, she knows she
can continue to remember the moment, that even when loving her
husband, she can "still dream of kissing Kitty again someday,
in a kitchen or at the beach as children shriek in the surf, aroused,
hopeless, in love with their own recklessness if not with each
other."
So, in the end, Clarissa's party for Richard goes on-but with a
much wider sense of celebration: the affirmation of the meaning
and beauty of life itself. She articulates her coming to terms with
the new purpose of the party: "It is in fact, a party, after
all. It is a party for the not-yet-dead; for the relatively
undamaged; for those who for mysterious reasons have the fortune
to be alive." The deeply wise humanity of Cunningham's writing
is humbling as he gently breaks our illusions of the ideals of
romantic love and guides us back to living and loving in the now,
in the ordinary, described in this exhilaratingly beautiful,
optimistic passage:
"We live our lives, do whatever we do, and then we sleep-it's
as simple and ordinary as that.There's just this for consolation:
an hour here or there when our lives seem, against all odds and
expectations, to burst open and give us everything we've ever
imagined, though everyone but children (and perhaps even they) knows
these hours will inevitably be followed by others, far darker and
more difficult. Still, we cherish the city in the morning; we hope,
more than anything, for more."
|